2019 Award Winners
- The Story Peddler by Lindsay Franklin – Book of the Year, Young Adult, Alliance Award
- Fierian by Ronie Kendig – Fantasy
- Fraught by Kerry Nietz- Science Fiction
- Shade: The Complete Trilogy by Merrie Destefano – Paranormal/Horror/Other
- Launch by Jason Joyner – Debut
- Never to Live by Just B. Jordan, Cover Design by Damonza – Parable Award
2018 Award Winners
- Firstborn by Tosca Lee – Book of the Year & Supernatural/Horror/Other
- The Button Girl by Sally Apokedak – Debut
- Renegades by Thomas Locke – Science Fiction
- The Songweaver’s Vow by Laura VanArendonk Baugh – Fantasy
- Milky Way Rising by Sharon Johnson – Young Adult
- Willoughby and the Terribly Itchy Itch by Pam Halter, illustrated by Kim Sponaugle – Children’s
- Warfare by Julie Hall – Alliance
- The Girl Who Could See by Kara Swanson, cover design by Jenny Zemanek – Parable
2017 Winners
- Frayed by Kerry Nietz Book of the Year & Science Fiction
- Terra Soul by S.J. Abraham – Debut
- A Green and Ancient Light by Frederic S. Durbin – Fantasy
- Ultimate Nyssa Glass by H.L. Burke – Young Adult
- Tainted by Morgan L. Busse – Other (Steampunk)
- A Time To Rise by Nadine Brandes – Alliance (Readers’ Choice)
- A Stolen Kiss by Kelsey Keating, cover design by Jenny Zemanek – Parable
2016 Winners
- The Mermaid’s Sister by Carrie Anne Noble – Book of the Year & Young Adult
- Into the Fire by Kim Vandel – Debut
- Hive by John Otte – Science Fiction
- The Shock of Night by Patrick Carr – Fantasy
- Amish Zombies from Space by Kerry Nietz – Supernatural/Horror/Other
- The Bloodheart by Steve Rzasa, cover design by Kirk DouPonce – Parable
2013 – 2015 Parable Award Winners
2015
The Ghost Box by Mike Duran, cover design by Kirk DouPonce
2014
Numb by John Otte, cover design by Alexandre Rito
2013
Divine Summons by Rebecca P. Minor, cover design by Christina Hess